Share |

MPT WWW
SEARCH

 

 



 

Canadian health care falls short of what we deserve
Whether it’s Swedish user fees or American health savings accounts, progressive alternatives exist


David Gratzer
The Globe and Mail
June 10, 2010

"Can you help me find a family doctor?" It's a question I’m asked practically every day in the hospital wards where I work. No wonder. According to the Canadian Medical Association, four million to five million people don't have a family physician.

The doctor shortage is a major problem with our health-care system. Unfortunately, it's just one of many. Our patients wait too long for basic care. The system is plagued by too much bureaucracy. And despite a massive infusion of money—the Ontario health budget has roughly doubled in the past decade—we must acknowledge what no government official is willing to admit: Canadian health care falls short of what we deserve.

There has been progress in reducing wait times in the five priority areas set out by the federal and provincial governments. Radiation therapy, for example, is delivered in a timelier manner in some cities across Canada than just a few years ago. But even drawing on government statistics—which are often inconsistent from province to province—Canadians wait too long for everything from surgeries like knee replacements (seven provinces fail to meet the benchmark wait times) to MRI scans (a majority of provinces aren't even collecting proper data yet). In other words, we're falling short, even after massive increases in spending, even by governments' own standards and data.

Two years after a parliamentary committee called unanimously for reform, we still lag behind many European countries on the introduction of new and orphan drugs to treat rare disorders. There are still too many tragedies. Think of the Montreal woman who died recently after waiting four days in a hospital ER, the last of a string of Quebec deaths that led the head of that province's College of Physicians to hope for a "miracle."

With so many problems, provincial governments are forced to spend hundreds of millions of dollars every year purchasing American health care for Canadians. Yes, our public dollars go to pay for their private health services.

Canadians, though, are routinely told how well our health-care system compares to those of other nations. It's not so. Take the United States. Despite the heated political rhetoric north of the 49th parallel about American health care, their patients are more likely to survive cancer (66.3 per cent over five years for American men, but 58 per cent for Canadian men, based on recent data from national databases). Their outcomes are also better for heart attacks and transplants. And, based on data from the Joint Canada/U.S. Survey of Health, Americans have greater access to preventive screening tests and higher treatment rates for chronic illnesses, and the poor under our public system seem to be less healthy relative to the non-poor than their American counterparts.

That's not an endorsement of an American-style system. Far from it. But for too long, we've looked south of the border and felt smug, very smug. In the coming years, we as a nation will spend more on health care but, as a new TD Economics report suggests, we can't simply spend, spend, spend given the limits of economic growth and the realities of an aging population. We need to look to other countries for ideas—even, yes, the United States.

We must emphasize health, and not just health care. Almost one in five adult Canadians is obese. A major cost driver in future years will be treating diseases (like hypertension and diabetes) that can often be prevented if people choose healthier lifestyles.

There is a role for the private sector in health-care delivery. Provincial governments have tried to do too much for too long. The Labour government led the way in Britain, for example, contracting out services to the private sector—even surgeries—and thus saving money and increasing capacity.

People need to pay more directly for their health care. The objective isn't to make a cancer patient burn her life savings to pay for her care—although this happens too often to some patients in Canada's health-care system, as seen in a survey of breast cancer survivors released by the Canadian Breast Cancer Network recently. No, the goal is to use limited cost-sharing to make sure patients don't see health care as "free" and abuse resources that should be directed to those in need. Whether it's Swedish user fees or American health savings accounts, progressive alternatives exist.

Canada has first-rate physicians and nurses—but a second-rate health-care system. Canadians deserve first-rate care capacity, first-rate health prevention and first-rate technology. And enough physicians and nurses to deliver it to our patients. And that is the system we deserve.

best buy buying online viagra viagra best buy deal online viagra viagra best buy for viagra best buy meridia phentermine propecia viagra best buy on line viagra best buy online com viagra best buy viagra best canadian pharmacy to buy viagra best place to buy viagra best place to buy viagra canada best way to buy viagra bulgaria buy viagra buy 100 mg viagra buy and purchase viagra online buy australian viagra buy buy viagra without prescription buy cailis viagra singapore buy canada viagra buy cheao cgeap kamagra uk viagra buy cheap cheap kamagra uk viagra buy cheap cialis generic levitra viagra buy cheap deal viagra viagra viagra buy cheap generic viagra buy cheap online prescription viagra buy cheap online uk viagra buy cheap online viagra buy cheap purchase uk viagra buy cheap purchase viagra buy cheap uk viagra buy cheap viagra buy cheap viagra 32 buy cheap viagra in uk buy cheap viagra on the net buy cheap viagra online buy cheap viagra online here buy cheap viagra online july buy cheap viagra online now buy cheap viagra online now uk buy cheap viagra online u buy cheap viagra online uk buy cheap viagra prescription online buy cheap viagra soft buy cheapest viagra buy cheapest viagra online buy chinese herbal viagra buy chinese herbal viagra duro buy cialis online viagra buy cialis viagra buy citrate com generic sildenafil viagra buy com online phentermine viagra buy diet viagra online buy discount online viagra buy discount viagra buy discount viagra on the internet buy discount viagra online buy discounted viagra buy discreet medical viagra buy discreet medical viagra drugs cheating buy drug generic generic online viagra buy female viagra buy form generic viagra buy generic online viagra buy generic soft tab viagra buy generic viagra buy generic viagra buy buy generic viagra cheap buy generic viagra img buy generic viagra in canada buy generic viagra india buy generic viagra off the shelf buy generic viagra on line buy generic viagra online buy generic viagra online pharmacy online buy generic viagra usa buy generic viagra without prescription buy get online prescription viagra buy hebal viagra buy herbal viagra buy herbal viagra jellies buy herbal viagra jellys buy herbal viagra longer erections buy internet viagra buy kamagra viagra buy kamagra viagra india buy lady uk viagra buy legal fda approved viagra buy levitra online viagra buy levitra viagra buy levitra viagra online buy line viagra buy locally viagra buy low price viagra buy n viagra buy no prior viagra cialis levitra buy non prescription generic viagra paypal buy now online viagra buy now viagra buy online com phentermine viagra buy online drug viagra pharmacy buy online levitra cialis viagra buy online order viagra buy online order viagra reliable drugstore buy online pharmacy viagra buy online pill viagra buy online prescription viagra buy online securely viagra buy online us viagra buy online viagra buy online viagra in the uk buy online viagra phentermine xanax buy online viagra securely buy phentermine buy online viagra viagra buy online viagra viagra viagra buy online viagra where buy onlinecom phentermine viagra buy overseas viagra buy pfizer viagra buy pharmaceutical viagra buy phentermine viagra buy phentermine viagra meridia ultr buy phentermine viagra online xanax buy phentramin viagra online buy pill viagra buy propecia com viagra xenical buy real viagra buy real viagra online pharmacy buy real viagra pharmacy online buy sildenafil viagra buy soft generic viagra cheapest buy softtabs viagra buy sublingual viagra on the internet buy sublingual viagra online buy taladafil viagra buy uk viagra buy viagra buy viagra $8 per pill buy viagra 1 buy viagra 100mg buy viagra 32 buy viagra 50mg buy viagra all information buy viagra alternative buy viagra and overseas buy viagra at a discount buy viagra at safeway buy viagra at the best price buy viagra australia buy viagra australian buy viagra bradenton buy viagra buy cheap viagra index buy viagra by pill buy viagra canada buy viagra canada review buy viagra canada warning buy viagra caverta buy viagra cheap buy viagra cheap fed ex buy viagra cheap india pharmacy buy viagra cheap online buy viagra cheap prices buy viagra cheap through online sales buy viagra cheap viagra order viagra buy viagra cheapest buy viagra cheapest best prices online buy viagra cheaply buy viagra cialis buy viagra cialis levitra buy viagra cialis online buy viagra contact us page buy viagra discrete england buy viagra discrete uk buy viagra fedex buy viagra for cheap buy viagra for less buy viagra for women buy viagra from an online pharmacy buy viagra from britain buy viagra from canada buy viagra from canada or mexico buy viagra from safeway buy viagra generic buy viagra here in the uk buy viagra iframe buy viagra iframe src buy viagra in amsterdam buy viagra in australia buy viagra in bangkok buy viagra in cagayan de oro buy viagra in canada buy viagra in el paso texas buy viagra in england buy viagra in great britain buy viagra in hong kong buy viagra in london buy viagra in london england buy viagra in malaysia buy viagra in mexico buy viagra in new zealand buy viagra in spain buy viagra in stoke on trent buy viagra in the netherlands buy viagra in the philippines buy viagra in the uk buy viagra in uk buy viagra in united kingdom buy viagra in vancouver buy viagra inte buy viagra internet buy viagra levitra alternative lavitra buy viagra line buy viagra locally buy viagra london buy viagra low cost buy viagra meds online buy viagra near las vegas buy viagra new york buy viagra no prescription buy viagra now buy viagra now online buy viagra on line buy viagra on line in uk buy viagra on line uk buy viagra on the internet buy viagra on the web insurance buy viagra on-line buy viagra onli buy viagra onli ne buy viagra online buy viagra online 3$ per pill buy viagra online 50mg buy viagra online a href buy viagra online alternative viagra buy viagra online and get prescription buy viagra online aramex buy viagra online at buy viagra online at cheap price buy viagra online at lowest price buy viagra online au buy viagra online australia buy viagra online buy buy viagra online canada buy viagra online canadian buy viagra online cheap buy viagra online cheapest buy viagra online discount buy viagra online get prescription buy viagra online in buy viagra online in australia buy viagra online in canada buy viagra online in uk buy viagra online india buy viagra online inu buy viagra online no prescription buy viagra online off pharmacy prices buy viagra online online buy viagra online online a href buy viagra online online pharmacy buy viagra online order buy viagra online order generic viagra buy viagra online pharmacy buy viagra online purchase buy viagra online uk buy viagra online web meds buy viagra online without prescription buy viagra onlines buy viagra or levitra buy viagra order viagra buy viagra over the counter buy viagra over the counter us buy viagra pay with paypal buy viagra per pill buy viagra pharmacy online buy viagra phentermine meridia adipex xenical buy viagra phentermine online pharmacy buy viagra phuket buy viagra pill buy viagra pill online buy viagra pills buy viagra prescription buy viagra prescription america buy viagra prescription online buy viagra price drugs on buy viagra professional buy viagra removethis buy viagra s diary buy viagra s journal buy viagra safeway pharmacy buy viagra safley buy viagra sale buy viagra search find free buy viagra securely online buy viagra ship fedex buy viagra soft buy viagra soft online buy viagra soft tabs buy viagra softtabs buy viagra tbilisi buy viagra the best quality pills buy viagra uk buy viagra uk online buy viagra ups buy viagra us pharmacy low prices buy viagra usa buy viagra using paypal buy viagra ventricular a href buy viagra viagra online buy viagra where buy viagra wholesale buy viagra with no prescription buy viagra with pay pal buy viagra with paypal buy viagra without a perscription buy viagra without a prescription buy viagra without prescription buy viagra without prescription online pharmacy buy viagra without prescription pharmacy online buy viagra zenegra buy xenical viagra propecia buy xenical viagra propecia com buy xenical viagra propecia com carisoprodol c-pill buy viagra can i buy viagra online can i buy viagra online w can i buy viagra with paypal can you buy viagra in mexico canada viagra buy chargeless buy cheap viagra online montgomery cheap amp fast buy online viagra cheap buy viagra cheap viagra buy pharmacy online now cheap viagra discount viagra buy viagra cheapest place buy viagra online cheapest place to buy viagra cheapest place to buy viagra online chinese viagra buy discount buy viagra drug manufacturers buy softtabs viagra easy buy viagra easy buy viagra online ebay bidding buy viagra ebay dding buy viagra find buy cheap viagra search generic find search viagra buy free find viagra free search 76k buy find viagra free sites search buy free sites computer search viagra buy generic cialis viagra caverta buy online generic viagra buy generic viagra buy form generic viagra buy online generic viagra buy sildenafil citrate generic viagra buy viagra online viagra good online place to buy viagra google groups buy viagra honest place to buy viagra how do you buy viagra at how to buy viagra how to buy viagra cheap how to buy viagra for cheap how to buy viagra from home how to buy viagra in philippines how to buy viagra on-line how to buy viagra online how to buy viagra without prescription how to safely buy viagra online india generic viagra buy one levitra buy levitra online viagra london uk buy generic viagra low-priced buy cheap viagra online garland online buy viagra online cheap viagra buy online games buy vitamins viagra sale online viagra buy viagra online tadalis paypal to buy viagra q buy viagra q buy viagra online rainbowpush discussion board buy viagra re buy viagra safest place to buy viagra safest site to buy viagra south beach diet buy viagra special offer buy viagra online to buy viagra how viagra and buy viagra best buy viagra best buy diet pills viagra buy viagra buy 1 viagra buy australia viagra buy best viagra buy contest viagra buy general viagra buy germany viagra buy in uk online viagra buy india viagra buy ionline viagra buy it online now viagra buy now pay later viagra buy on line viagra buy online viagra buy oonline viagra buy pharmacy iframe viagra buy price iframe viagra buy uk viagra buy uk amsterdam viagra buy usa viagra buy viagra viagra buy viagra online viagra cheap buy online viagra cheap uk buy purchase viagra cialis buy safe paypal viagra cialis levitra buy viagra viagra drug store best buys viagra find buy cheap search generic viagra find viagra sites search buy viagra free sites computer search buy viagra memphis tn buy viagra online buy viagra prescription buy viagra propecia buy online viagra purchase buy viagra sale buy viagra soft tabs uk buy viagra to buy viagra to buy cheap viagra uk buy online viagra uk cheap purchase buy viagra viagra buy viagra viagra buy search find viagra viagra buy search find free viagra viagra online buy viagra viagra without buy prescription wanted to buy viagra wanted too buy viagra warning buy viagra now we to buy viagra online webresults buy viagra where buy viagra where can i buy generic viagra where can i buy viagra where can i buy viagra in where can i buy viagra online where can you buy viagra cheap where do i buy viagra in where do i buy viagra online where to buy generic viagra where to buy viagra where to buy viagra forum where to buy viagra in bahrain where to buy viagra in bangkok where to buy viagra in beijing where to buy viagra in canada where to buy viagra in chennai where to buy viagra in england where to buy viagra in india where to buy viagra in nz where to buy viagra on line where to buy viagra online where to buy viagra safe sitemap sildenafil find vardenafil $2.00 calias viagra $2.00 viagra $2 viagra 1 day viagra 1 generic viagra 100 mg viagra 100mg viagra 10mg viagra 10 min viagra 110mg viagra 150 mg viagra 2 free viagra 200 mg viagra 222 pill viagra 25mg viagra 250mg viagra 250 mg viagra 25 mg viagra 3 generic viagra 3.61 purchase viagra 3.98 order viagra 30sec viagra 36 hour viagra David Gratzer is a physician and author. He is participating in tonight's Munk Debate, with the resolution: "Be it resolved: I would rather get sick in the U.S. than Canada."

 
home   spotlight   commentary   research   events   news   about   contact   links   archives
Copyright Manhattan Institute for Policy Research
52 Vanderbilt Avenue
New York, NY 10017
(212) 599-7000
mpt@manhattan-institute.org